This episode of the Plastic Podcast is the first half of a conversation about the Academy Award nominations. Rob and J. Robert talk about the Best Picture and Best Director categories.
0:00 Intro
1:16 Avatar
7:21 Expansion of the Best Picture Category
10:17 Our Favorite and Least Favorite Nominees
12:03 An Education
14:01 Up in the Air
18:20 The Hurt Locker
20:51 Precious
22:30 2009 as a Whole/Hole
27:31 District 9
29:15 The Blind Side Blind
30:30 Inglourious Basterds
35:18 Outro
Further Reading
- Our previous chat about the Coens' A Serious Man
- Rob's review of Inglourious Basterds
- List of Oscar nominees


Welcome back, guys! Great show, perfectly spot-on on several of the nominees, most notably The Hurt Locker and Up In The Air, whose failings amidst its appeal you really nailed. Why do so many people- especially certain pro critics- love the latter film so much? My theory is that it's this season's Sideways: it asks its audience to identify with a central character that for various reasons is particularly easy for the type of person who has chosen criticism as a career to identify with. I was going to parallel the various ways Clooney resembles a working film critic, but it started sounding like a bitter screed so I'm holding off; I don't mean it that way at all. But I do think when Reitman found this character he knew what he had, and his studio was able to position his film as a successful Oscar picture in no small part because of this critic-pleasing aspect of the film.
Brian — February 28th, 2010 at 1:46 pm